Select Page

biweekly column

Readers, please look for my column that I completed today, some ideas on Jonathan Winthrop’s sermon “A Model of Christian Charity.” It should post in a few days.

War and peace in Ukraine

War and peace in Ukraine

War and peace in Ukraine

On February 17, 2023, David Remnick of the New Yorker podcast interviewed Steven Kotkin, history professor at Stanford, and biographer of Joseph Stalin.

Kotkin said, “Let’s think of a house with ten rooms, and let’s say I barge in and take two of those rooms. I wreck those two rooms, and I also wreck your other eight rooms. You try to evict me, but I’m still there wrecking your entire house.

“You need your house. That’s where you live. You don’t have another house. Me, I’ve got another house, and my house has a thousand rooms. So, if I wreck your house, are you winning, or am I winning?”

On Friday, February 24, 2022, the world marked the one-year anniversary of Vladimir Putin’s invasion into Ukraine, in order, he said, “to de-militarize and de-Nazify Ukraine,” an inadequate or invalid reason, if not sheer propaganda.

Some argue that Putin’s true reasons were that he wanted to re-establish the old Soviet Union, or that he wanted to seize more land, or that he was terrified of a united Ukraine joining the European Union.

Whatever his reasons, Putin’s “special military operation” has turned into a tragedy.

Staggering for the Russians is the heavy loss of military equipment: 299 aircraft, 288 helicopters, 3381 tanks, 6615 armored combat vehicles, 5242 vehicles and fuel tankers, and 2037 tactical unmanned aircraft.

Yet, more tragic are the Russian army’s casualties: 148,130 military personnel. In February, the average number of Russian troops killed per day jumped to 842.

Putin’s draft now pulls poorly fed and barely trained conscripts from jails, mental health facilities, hospitals, and warm bodies off the streets, and hands them a gun, with an order to “march forward until they are killed.” This is a brutal, bloody war.

Millions of Ukrainians have fled, living miles from their wrecked country.

Kotkin says, that the war has revealed three pleasant surprises: “Ukraine’s strong resistance, Russia’s poor performance in battle, and the European Union’s unification.”

That the German government is about to send tanks to Ukraine must conjure up terror and nightmares among Russian governing officials and citizens.

Fresh in the Russian people’s collective memory are the 27 million Russian people who lost their lives in World War II, when the German Nazi military machine marched across Central Europe, deep into Russia, causing indescribable destruction.

Kotkin says that Zalensky and Ukrainian officials want three things before peace can happen: “captured Ukrainian territory returned to Ukraine, reparations for property damages, and a tribunal for war crimes.”

Kotkin points out, “that would mean the Ukrainians would have to take Moscow.”

Reparations alone are “estimated at $350 billion in U.S. dollars, when Ukraine’s GDP in 2021, prior to the war, was only $180 billion, just over half of the estimated cost.”

How can anyone stop this bloody war? How can anyone win a peace?

Some possibilities. Start small, with a cease fire for say, a day or a weekend. Draw on a map two red parallel battlelines, and call the land between them, a demilitarized zone. Both sides give up territory in exchange for something else that they want.

According to Kotkin, “a victory for Ukraine” would include entry or “accession into the European Union,” a condition that the Ukrainians crave.

In the podcast, David Remnick reminded Steven Kotkin of Sun Tzu’s quote. The ancient Chinese general said, “Build your opponent a golden bridge to retreat across.”

Kotkin said, “That would be great, but nothing like that is in sight now.”

What is in sight now is a wrecked house.

St. Valentine’s Day / Presidents Day

St. Valentine’s Day / Presidents Day

We celebrated St. Valentine’s Day yesterday, February 14, a day when we reflect upon our good fortune that we have that special person in our life, our Valentine.

Next Monday, February 20, government officials grant us a holiday to consider the forty-five Presidents, all men. Because Grover Cleveland served two non-consecutive terms, officials count him twice, as #24 and #26. Thus, we give honor to forty-four men.

First President George Washington was born on February 11, 1731, by the Julian calendar, but after British officials adopted the Gregorian calendar in 1752, his official birthday was moved to February 22, 1732, a full year and eleven days later.

As far is known, Washington loved his wife Martha and was faithful to her. Throughout the American Revolutionary War, 1775-1783, he may have returned to their home in Mount Vernon, Virginia, once, in September of 1781, just prior to the final battle at Yorktown.

Martha though joined him often at the front lines, and then, years later, after George was elected President in 1786, they moved into the Macomb House in New York City, the seat of the Federal Government then, and remained there together for two four-year terms.

If George Washington had a prior Valentine, it was for Virginia, his first and constant love.

Second President John Adams loved Abigail his wife. There is no evidence of any mistress. John and Abigail wrote hundreds of letters to each other throughout their married life, whenever he was away. If John had a Valentine, it was for Independence from Great Britain.

Third President Thomas Jefferson is a more complicated enigma.

He married Martha Skelton, on January 1, 1772, and over the next ten years she gave birth to six children, but just two lived, Martha and Maria. The pregnancies weakened Martha’s body and contributed to her premature passing on September 6, 1782, at the age of thirty-three.

Jefferson was overcome with deep sorrow. Locked in his room, over several days, the future President paced the floor, until his grief began to subside. His daughter Martha wrote, “The violence of his emotion. To this day I cannot describe it to myself.”

Much has been written in recent years about the relationship between Thomas Jefferson and his slave Sally Hemings, after his wife’s passing. Sally also gave birth to six children. What is odd is that Jefferson’s wife Martha and Sally shared the same dad, and thus were half-sisters.

You can read how the historian Fawn Brodie sifted through the data in her 1974 book, Thomas Jefferson, An Intimate History, or how Annette Gordon-Reed did the same in her 2009 book, The Hemingses of Monticello: An American Family.

The two historians, and others, concluded that Thomas Jefferson most likely took a mistress, a young biracial slave girl named Sally Hemings, an example of “the South’s culture, that of immense hypocrisy, and terrific moral problems, not easily solved.” She was his Valentine.

Fourth President James Madison was devoted to his wife Dolley. Raised a Quaker, she displayed a happy personality and a warm heart. “To this day she remains one of the best known and best loved women of the White House.” In Dolley, James won a Valentine.

Sixteenth President Abraham Lincoln was born on February 12, 1809. He and Mary Todd, his wife, shared one thing, their joint ambition for him to attain the Presidency, and that they did.

However, their differences were well defined. His best quality was his sense of humor that he used to disarm his enemies. He failed though with Mary Todd, who had no sense of humor.

Of her husband, she was bitter and said, “He is of no account when he is at home. He never does anything except to warm himself and read. He never went to the market in his life. I must look after all that. He is the most useless, good-for-nothing man on earth.”

It is no wonder that he said, “Most folks are as happy as they make up their minds to be.”

If Lincoln ever had a Valentine, it was his love for his sons and his love for the Union.

If a president can win and retain a sweet Valentine, it helps to ease the burdens of the job.

Groundhog Day

Groundhog Day

On February 4, 1977, the band Fleetwood Mac released their record-selling “Rumours” album. Lindsey Buckingham and Christine McVie sang one of its songs, “Don’t Stop.”

“If you wake up and don’t want to smile. If it takes just a little while. Open your eyes and look at the day. You’ll see things in a different way. Don’t stop thinking about tomorrow. Don’t stop. It’ll soon be here. It’ll be better than before. Yesterday’s gone. Yesterday’s gone.”

Last week, for the first time, I watched Bill Murray play the part of Phil Connors, in the movie “Groundhog Day.” For a romantic comedy, I would say that it was ok, even better than ok.

Phil Connors is an arrogant, obnoxious weather forecaster, who works at a Pittsburgh television station. His boss sends him to Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania, eighty miles away, to report on the town’s annual Groundhog Day celebration, set for February 2.

With his producer Rita and cameraman Larry, Connors drives to Punxsutawney on February 1. The next morning, February 2, an alarm clock awakens Connors at 6:00 a.m., in a bed inside the town’s bed and breakfast. The radio plays Sonny and Cher singing, “I’ve Got You Babe.”

A radio DJ then says, “OK, campers, rise and shine, and don’t forget your booties, because it’s cold out there! The National Weather Service is calling for a big blizzard thing today.”

Connors meets Rita and Larry at Gobler’s Knob in the town square to watch the groundhog come out of its box. Connors looks into Larry’s camera and speaks. Rita watches and approves, even though Connors acts and talks in a condescending way about the town’s citizens.

Once the groundhog sees its shadow, an official declares that winter will last six more weeks.

Connors, Rita, and Larry drive out of Punxsutawney, but a blizzard forces them back to the town. The next morning at 6:00 a.m., in his bed, Connors awakens to hear “I’ve Got You Babe,” and the DJ repeats word for word his call for a big blizzard. Connors thinks this odd.

Outside, he notices people walking to Gobler’s Knob. He asks someone what day it is and learns that it is February 2, Groundhog Day. He meets Rita and Larry, but they do not remember that they completed all this yesterday. Larry films Phil a second time.

No one else in Punxsutawney remembers, only Phil Connors.

The next morning at 6:00 a.m., he awakens to hear Sonny and Cher singing, “I’ve Got You Babe,” and to the DJ predicting a blizzard. It is again February 2, Groundhog Day. The same thing happens the next day, and the next day, dozens, perhaps hundreds of times.

He soon realizes that tomorrow never arrives. Every new morning is February 2. He is stuck in a time loop, a Twilight Zone, and Phil Connors never learns how or why this is happening.

He tries to explain his predicament to Rita, his lovely television associate, saying,

“Well, what if there is no tomorrow? There wasn’t one today.” “It’s like yesterday never happened.” “What would you do if you were stuck in one place, and every day was exactly the same, and nothing you did mattered?”

“Rita, if you only had one day to live, what would you do with it?” “I wake up every day right here in Punxsutawney, and it’s always February 2. And there’s nothing I can do about it.” “Now, tomorrow, you will have forgotten all about this. And you’ll treat me like a jerk.”

Phil kills himself again and again, but the next morning he awakens in his bed at 6:00 a.m.

He settles down and takes some baby steps to improve himself. He learns to play the piano. With a chainsaw, he makes an ice sculpture. He learns to speak French. He helps people in town, and they call him “Doctor.” He treats Rita better and falls in love with her.

One critic wrote, “Phil must figure out how to arrest the cycle. The secret, it transpires, lies within him.” Another wrote, “Change arises from repetition. The film follows that to the letter.”

“Groundhog Day,” was first released on February 4, 1993, thirty years ago this week, and to celebrate its anniversary, movie officials plan to release the film this month in select theaters.

“Don’t stop thinking about tomorrow.” Phil Connors never did.

Profiles in Courage

Profiles in Courage

John F. Kennedy served in the U. S. Congress for fourteen years, from 1947 until 1960.

Born in Brookline, Massachusetts, JFK was first elected to the House of Representatives in 1946, and he stayed there until 1952, a total of six years. In 1952, he ran for Senate, won the election and stayed there from 1953 to 1960, a total of eight years.

He was elected President of the United States in November 1960, and in January of 1961, he and his wife Jackie, and their two children, Caroline and John, Jr., moved into the White House, where he served three years as President, until his life ended on November 22, 1963.

Takeaways from his career. JFK never lost an election, although the presidential election in 1960, Kennedy vs. Nixon, was one of the closest ever. Nixon chose to concede rather than call for a recount.

Second, when still young, JFK enjoyed rare political success. He was twenty-nine when first elected to the House, thirty-six when elected to the Senate, and forty-three when elected President.

Today, we remember him as a former President, but he was also a former long-time Congressman.

In 1954, when in the Senate, Kennedy endured a second back surgery, an ailment that carried over from his days playing football at Harvard College. The surgery though failed to diminish his pain.

During his leave of absence from the Senate chamber, he came across a quote from Herbert Agar’s book, The Price of Union, about John Quincy Adams’s courage when he served in Congress.

Political courage had long intrigued Kennedy. During his senior year at Harvard College, he wrote his dissertation about “the failure of British political leaders in the 1930’s to oppose popular resistance to rearming, leaving the country ill-prepared for World War II.”

A publisher published that thesis under the title Why England Slept in 1940, and 80,000 copies sold.

Kennedy showed that quote from Herbert Agar’s book to his speechwriter Ted Sorensen, and asked him to find other examples of Senators, who had displayed unusual political courage at crucial times in their careers. Sorensen came back with eight examples.

In addition to John Quincy Adams of Massachusetts, Sorensen included Daniel Webster also of Massachusetts, Thomas Hart Benton of Missouri, Sam Houston of Texas, Edmund G. Ross of Kansas, Lucius Lamar of Mississippi, George Norris of Nebraska, and Robert Taft of Ohio.

Although Ted Sorensen wrote the book’s first draft, Kennedy’s name appeared on the book’s title page as author. Profiles in Courage was a best-seller and won the Pulitzer Prize for Biography in 1957.

Years later, in 1989, the Kennedy family established the “Profiles in Courage” prize, and the next year, prize officials named their first recipient, Carl Elliott, Sr.

In 1999, John McCain received the award, Gerald Ford in 2001, Ted Kennedy in 2009, George H. W. Bush in 2014, Barack Obama in 2017, Nancy Pelosi in 2019, and Mitt Romney in 2021.

Officials defended that last selection, saying, “Romney was the first Senator to have ever voted to convict a President of his own party. Senator Mitt Romney’s courageous stand was historic.”

In May of 2022, prize officials, for the first time, named five individuals: Volodymyr Zelenskyy, President of Ukraine; Liz Cheney, now a former Congresswoman from Wyoming; Jocelyn Benson, (no relation), Michigan’s Secretary of State; Russell Bowers, Arizona’s House Speaker; and Wandrea’ ArShaye Moss, a former elections department employee in Fulton County, Georgia.

Officials gathered the five under the collective title, “Defending Democracy at Home and Abroad.”

Zelenskyy united Ukraine’s citizens to withstand Putin’s aggressive strike at their homeland.

After the 2020 election, Liz Cheney urged “President Trump to respect the rulings of the courts and his oath of office, and to support the peaceful transfer of power. When Trump rejected the 2020 election’s results, she broke with her party, urged fidelity to the Constitution, and stood her ground.”

“Jocelyn Benson, Michigan’s chief elections officer, also did not waver, but defended the will of Michigan voters and assured them that she would protect and defend Michigan’s vote.” As a result of her stand, “she received threats and harassment from then-President Trump and his allies.”

“Russell Bowers endured persistent harassment and intimidation tactics from Trump supporters, and survived an attempt to recall him from Arizona’s legislature.”

Wandrea’ ArShaye Moss “became the target of a vicious smear campaign by then-President Trump and his allies. They falsely accused her of processing fake ballots for Biden in the late-night hours of Election Day. Moss then received so many death threats and racist taunts that she went into hiding.”

For Liz Cheney, the persecution continued after the 2020 election.

“Trump made it his personal mission to defeat her in the August 2022 primary, throwing his weight behind a handpicked Republican opponent, Harriet Hageman.” “Hageman won. Cheney conceded. It was the way democracy worked, once upon a time in America.” She leaves Congress this month.

Conceding an election without drama and theatrics is a prime example of a profile in courage.